The Golden Goose of ETH ETFs 🥚
Happy Sunday dispatchers!
Andrew Carnegie once famously opined that "90% of all millionaires become so through owning real estate." The appeal was simple: real estate produces two streams of income — the appreciation of the property and the rent it generates along the way.
Fast forward to 2025, and the crypto world stands at a similar inflection point. While Bitcoin ETFs have enjoyed a meteoric rise, attracting $35 billion since their January 2024 launch, Ethereum ETFs have struggled to keep pace, pulling in a comparatively modest $2.3 billion.
Time could change fast though.
What if ETH ETFs could offer both appreciation and yield? This is precisely the promise of Ethereum ETF staking — the regulatory holy grail that could finally give ether funds their Carnegie moment.
The clock is ticking.
Staking approval could come as early as next month, with final decisions expected by October, as per Bloomberg Intelligence analyst James Seyffart. The race is on, and the stakes couldn't be higher.
If he's right, we're standing at the precipice of a transformation that could reshape not just crypto funds, but how mainstream finance thinks about digital assets altogether.
Let’s take it from the top.
Secure your Bitcoin with Hardware Wallets
Trezor has transformed crypto security from a complex puzzle to a user-friendly playground, so you can be the boss of your financial future.
Securely store, manage, and protect your coins with Trezor hardware wallets, app & backup solutions.
When Ethereum completed "The Merge" in September 2022, it transitioned from the energy-intensive proof-of-work model (Bitcoin's approach) to proof-of-stake. This fundamental shift meant that ETH holders could now "stake" their tokens — essentially locking them up to help secure the network — and earn rewards in return.
These rewards typically range from 3% to 4% annually, coming from newly minted ETH and transaction fees. Stakers provide a valuable service by validating transactions and securing the network. The more ETH staked, the more secure Ethereum becomes.
There's a catch: traditional staking requires a minimum of 32 ETH (roughly $50,000 at current prices) and enough technical expertise to make your average financial advisor break into hives. It's like trying to collect rent on a building you have to assemble yourself using a cryptic instruction manual in a foreign language.
This is precisely where ETF staking could revolutionise the game.
When the SEC finally relented on Ethereum ETFs in June 2024, it did so with a catch — no staking allowed. Gary Gensler's commission viewed staking rewards with suspicious eyes, worried that they might transform ETH into a security under the dreaded Howey Test.
The result? ETH ETFs were born with a competitive handicap. It's like launching a dividend stock ETF but prohibiting the companies from paying dividends — you're left with only half the value proposition.
The ETH funds have seen net inflows of around $2.4 billion as of April 10, compared to $35 billion for Bitcoin ETFs introduced in January, as per data from Farside Investors.
"There's no question it's less perfect for ETH today without staking. A staking yield is a meaningful part of how you can generate investment return in this space," says BlackRock Digital Assets Head Robert Mitchnick.
In a world where fixed-income investors still pine for decent yields, ETH's staking rewards of 3-4% look positively mouthwatering.
Get 17% discount on our annual plans and access our weekly premium features (Mempool, Game On, News Rollups, HashedIn, Wormhole and Rabbit hole) and subscribers only posts. Also, show us some love on Twitter and Telegram.
The Alchemy of Staking
ETF staking would democratise the staking process, turning a complex technical procedure into a passive investment strategy accessible to anyone with a brokerage account.
Here's how it would work:
The ETF issuer allocates a portion of the fund's ETH holdings for staking — likely 25-50% to balance yield with liquidity needs.
Either directly or through service providers, they establish validator nodes on the Ethereum network.
These validators earn rewards in newly minted ETH and transaction fees.
After covering operational costs, the staking rewards are distributed to ETF investors as dividends or reinvested to compound returns.
This yield comes from three sources:
Protocol rewards: New ETH issued by the protocol to incentivise validators
Transaction fees: A portion of fees paid by users
MEV (Maximal Extractable Value): Additional value extracted by ordering transactions within blocks
The current staking yield on Ethereum hovers between 3-4% annually. For ETF investors, this might translate to 2-3% after management fees and operational costs — not life-changing, perhaps, but a compelling sweetener in today's investment landscape.
"It's not as simple as...a new administration just green-lighting something and then boom, we're all good, off to the races," Mitchnick cautioned.
He's right. The mechanics are complex.
ETF issuers must consider how much ETH to stake, how to manage validator infrastructure, and how to handle the risks of slashing penalties if their validators misbehave.
But the potential rewards make these challenges worth tackling.
Got questions about a hot crypto topic that you want help understanding? Ask your question using the form and our crypto experts may answer it along with your name in the next Thursday’s News Rollups.
The ETH Advantage
If staking gets approved, ETH ETFs would suddenly have a significant edge over their BTC counterparts. While Bitcoin ETFs rely solely on price appreciation, Ethereum ETFs could offer both capital gains and consistent yield.
1/ Dual Return Sources: You get price appreciation and staking yield.
2/ Income Generation: Regular dividend-like income from staking rewards.
3/ Compounding Potential: If staking rewards get reinvested, the magic of compounding kicks in.
Think of it as the difference between owning gold and owning a dividend-paying stock.
Both have their merits, but the latter gives investors something tangible to hold onto during volatile periods.
This yield component is particularly valuable in institutional portfolios that require income generation alongside growth potential.
Pension funds, endowments, and wealth managers — all of whom have been gradually warming to crypto exposure — might find the staking yield to be the deciding factor that finally gets them off the sidelines.
The timing is perfect. As interest rates potentially ease in the coming years, the search for yield will intensify. A 3% yield from a regulated ETF that also offers exposure to the second-largest cryptocurrency? That's a compelling proposition.
Let's not forget the ecosystem benefits. More ETH locked in staking means greater security for the Ethereum network and potentially less circulating supply — a double positive for price stability and potential appreciation.
The Players at the Plate
As the regulatory winds shift, several major ETF issuers are positioning themselves at the starting line: Bitwise Asset Management has filed for staking approval via NYSE Arca and acquired London-based crypto firm Attestant to bolster their staking capabilities. Their ETHW ETF is positioned as an early staking adopter.
BlackRock's iShares Ethereum Trust (ETHA) has significant market presence and institutional relationships. With approximately $2.3 billion in assets under management, they stand to gain substantially from staking approval.
Fidelity is pursuing staking approval through Cboe BZX Exchange, leveraging their extensive retail and institutional distribution networks.
Grayscale's Ethereum Trust ETF (ETHE), one of the largest ETH ETFs, is working to transition from a premium/discount model to a more efficient staking model.
The first mover advantage here is significant. The initial ETFs to implement staking could capture outsized market share in what might quickly become a competitive space.
The Ecosystem Benefits
The implementation of staking in ETH ETFs would benefit fund investors and strengthen the entire Ethereum ecosystem:
Currently, over 34 million ETH (approximately 27% of the total supply, valued at over $121 billion) is staked across the network.
The Regulatory Minefield
Of course, nothing in crypto is ever simple, especially when regulators are involved. Several hurdles remain.
Security Classification: The SEC must decide whether staked ETH constitutes a security under the Howey Test.
Custody Requirements: Regulatory requirements for custodying staked assets add complexity. Disclosure Standards: ETFs must adequately disclose the risks and mechanics of staking to investors.
Tax Implications: The tax treatment of staking rewards within ETF structures requires clarification.
But the competitive landscape has changed dramatically. With a more crypto-friendly administration in place, the consensus seems to be shifting toward approval.
NYSE Arca's recent filing on behalf of the Bitwise Ethereum ETF and Cboe BZX's similar proposal for Fidelity suggest that the industry believes the timing is right.
The staking advantage is so compelling that some issuers might even consider using staking rewards to offset management fees, potentially offering zero or near-zero fee structures to attract investors.
Token Dispatch View 🔍
Andrew Carnegie understood that real estate's genius lies in its dual-income stream. Ethereum staking ETFs stand poised to bring that same investment alchemy to the crypto world. For ETH ETFs struggling to emerge from Bitcoin's shadow, staking could be the decisive advantage — the golden goose that transforms them from mere speculation vehicles into genuine yield-producing investments.
The stage is set for a potential turning point in crypto adoption. If regulators give their blessing to ETH ETF staking, it will mark another significant step in crypto's long march toward mainstream financial legitimacy.
Ethereum staking represents something truly rare in modern finance: a technological mechanism for generating yield that isn't dependent on central bank policy or financial engineering. It's yield derived from providing a tangible service — securing a network that powers thousands of applications and holds billions in value.
This matters beyond attracting more money into crypto ETFs. It represents a fundamental shift in how we think about digital assets — not as speculative investments but as productive capital.
Consider the implications: If ETH ETFs successfully implement staking, what's next? Could we see similar products for Solana, Cardano, or other proof-of-stake networks? Could DEX tokens that distribute trading fees to holders eventually find their way into similar regulated products? The SEC's upcoming decision on ETH ETF staking is about whether cryptocurrency can begin to fill the yield-shaped hole that exists in modern financial markets.
If staking approval comes through, it won't just mark a win for Ethereum or ETF issuers. It will signal that crypto has graduated from pure speculation to productive finance. And that's a golden egg worth waiting for.
Week That Was 📆
Saturday: How Big Is Trump’s IRS Rule Reversal Crypto Win? 🏦
Thursday: The Decoupling Dilemma 📊
Wednesday: The Knockout: McGregor's Token Failure 🥋
Token Dispatch is a daily crypto newsletter handpicked and crafted with love by human bots. You can find all about us here 🙌
If you want to reach out to 200,000+ subscriber community of the Token Dispatch, you can explore the partnership opportunities with us.
Disclaimer: This newsletter contains sponsored content and affiliate links. All sponsored content is clearly marked. Opinions expressed by sponsors or in sponsored content are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of this newsletter or its authors. We may receive compensation from featured products/services. Content is for informational purposes only, not financial advice. Trading crypto involves substantial risk - your capital is at risk. Do your own research.